C-LIGHT telephone TEL:+86 132 6656 7067    
Language
C-LIGHT search

NPO vs On-Board Optics: Optical Integration, Electrical Path, and Switch Architecture

By C-LIGHT Marketing 丨 Jun 6, 2025
Table of Contents

    NPO-vs-On-Board-Optics.jpg

    As data center switch bandwidth increases, the physical distance between the switching ASIC and optical engine becomes an increasingly important part of system architecture. Traditional pluggable optics place transceivers at the front panel, while newer integration approaches move optical conversion closer to the switching silicon to reduce high-speed electrical channel length.

    Two approaches in this transition are On-Board Optics (OBO) and Near-Packaged Optics (NPO). OBO mounts optical engines directly on the system printed circuit board (PCB), typically near the switch ASIC. NPO takes integration further by placing the ASIC package and optical engines on a shared high-performance substrate or interposer, depending on the implementation.

    Both approaches aim to reduce the electrical distance between electronic and optical components. Their main difference is how the ASIC and optical engine are physically connected, which affects signal integrity, power consumption, packaging complexity, thermal management, and maintenance.

    1. What Is On-Board Optics (OBO)?

    On-Board Optics is an optical integration architecture in which optical engines are mounted directly on the system PCB rather than installed in front-panel transceiver cages.

    The switch ASIC remains in its own semiconductor package, while the optical engines are positioned nearby on the same circuit board. High-speed electrical signals travel from the ASIC package through PCB traces to the optical engines, where they are converted into optical signals for transmission over fiber.

    A typical OBO implementation includes:

    • Switch ASIC: Processes network packets and provides high-speed electrical interfaces.

    • ASIC package: Connects the switching silicon to the system PCB.

    • PCB electrical routing: Carries high-speed signals between the ASIC package and optical engines.

    • Electrical engine (EIC): Provides the electronic functions required to drive or receive high-speed signals.

    • Photonic integrated circuit (PIC): Performs optical modulation, detection, and other photonic functions.

    • Fiber interface: Connects the optical engine to external fiber-optic infrastructure.

    Typical On-Board Optics Architecture
    Switch ASIC
    →
    ASIC Package
    ↓
    PCB Electrical Traces
    →
    OBO Optical Engine
    ↓
    Fiber Interface
    →
    External Fiber Network

    Conceptual architecture: the ASIC and optical engine are separate components mounted on the same system PCB.

    OBO shortens the electrical connection compared with front-panel pluggable optics because the optical engine can be positioned close to the ASIC. However, the high-speed electrical channel still travels through the PCB.

    This arrangement offers an intermediate integration approach: it reduces the distance between electronic and optical components without requiring the optical engine to share a dedicated high-performance substrate with the ASIC package.

    2. What Is Near-Packaged Optics (NPO)?

    Near-Packaged Optics places optical engines closer to the switch ASIC through a more integrated packaging arrangement. Rather than mounting the optical engine independently on the main system PCB, NPO commonly uses a high-performance substrate or interposer to support the ASIC package and nearby optical engines.

    The purpose is to create a shorter and more controlled electrical connection between the switching silicon and optical conversion components.

    A representative NPO architecture includes:

    • Switch ASIC package: Contains the main switching silicon and its package-level electrical connections.

    • High-performance substrate or interposer: Provides the electrical routing between the ASIC package and optical engines.

    • Optical engine: Combines the relevant electronic and photonic components for optical signal conversion.

    • Fiber attachment: Provides the optical path between the engine and external fiber infrastructure.

    • System PCB: Supports the overall assembly and connects it to the remaining switch electronics.

    Typical Near-Packaged Optics Architecture
    Switch ASIC
    ↔
    NPO Optical Engine
    Shared High-Performance Substrate / Interposer
    ↓
    System PCB
    Switch Infrastructure
    ↓
    Fiber Interface
    →
    External Fiber Network

    Conceptual NPO arrangement. High-speed ASIC-to-optical-engine connections are routed through the shared high-performance substrate rather than relying on long main-PCB traces.

    In this architecture, the optical engine can remain a separate component from the ASIC package. Some NPO implementations use socketed or separately assembled optical engines, allowing the electronic and optical components to be tested independently before final integration.

    The exact definition of NPO can vary among industry proposals and vendors. Some designs emphasize a shared substrate, while others use different interposer or near-package assembly arrangements. The actual package structure and serviceability should therefore be confirmed against the specific platform design.

    3. NPO vs On-Board Optics: Key Technical Differences

    The main distinction between NPO and OBO is the substrate used to connect the optical engine to the switch ASIC. OBO relies on the main system PCB, while NPO uses a closer high-performance substrate or interposer arrangement.

    Technical DimensionOn-Board Optics (OBO)Near-Packaged Optics (NPO)
    Optical engine locationMounted on the system PCB near the ASICPositioned near the ASIC on a shared high-performance substrate or interposer
    ASIC connectionThrough PCB tracesThrough a shorter substrate-level electrical connection
    Electrical pathASIC package to PCB to optical engineASIC package to shared substrate to optical engine
    PCB high-speed routingUsed for the ASIC-to-optical-engine connectionCan be avoided for the primary high-speed ASIC-to-engine connection
    Electrical channelShorter than traditional front-panel pluggablesTypically shorter and more tightly controlled than OBO
    Signal integrityDepends on PCB material, routing, transitions, and channel lossBenefits from substrate-level electrical routing and shorter channel length
    Power efficiencyPotential improvement over front-panel opticsPotential further improvement through reduced electrical channel loss
    Integration densityLimited by PCB placement and routing constraintsCan provide closer and denser optical-engine integration
    Thermal designOptical engines distributed across the system PCBOptical engines located closer to the high-power ASIC package
    ManufacturingRequires board-level optical-engine assembly and testingRequires tighter coordination of ASIC packaging, substrate, and optical-engine assembly
    MaintenanceDepends on the mounting and fiber-interface designDepends on whether the optical engine is socketed, removable, or permanently assembled
    Integration complexityBoard-level integrationMore demanding substrate-level integration

    Neither architecture has a universal advantage in every system. NPO can provide a shorter electrical path, but its benefits depend on substrate design, optical-engine implementation, thermal management, and manufacturing capability.

    4. Electrical Signal Path and Signal Integrity

    Electrical channel quality is a major reason for moving optical engines closer to the switch ASIC. As SerDes lane rates increase, PCB traces become more challenging because electrical signals experience insertion loss, reflections, crosstalk, and frequency-dependent attenuation.

    In an OBO design, the signal travels from the ASIC package through the system PCB to the optical engine. Even when the optical engine is placed close to the ASIC, PCB routing remains part of the high-speed electrical channel.

    In an NPO design, the high-speed connection can be routed through a shared high-performance substrate or interposer. This reduces reliance on the main PCB for the ASIC-to-optical-engine connection and allows tighter control of the electrical path.

    Signal Integrity FactorOBONPO
    Routing mediumMain system PCBHigh-performance substrate or interposer
    Electrical distanceShortened compared with front-panel opticsGenerally further reduced through substrate-level integration
    Insertion lossDepends on PCB channel length and material propertiesCan benefit from a shorter, more controlled electrical channel
    Impedance controlPCB traces, vias, and component transitionsSubstrate routing and package-level transitions
    Design focusBoard routing and optical-engine placementSubstrate design, package interfaces, and optical-engine placement

    A shorter channel can reduce the equalization and signal-conditioning burden, but it does not eliminate electrical design challenges. Substrate materials, impedance discontinuities, package transitions, crosstalk, and manufacturing tolerances remain important.

    Engineering distinction: OBO moves the optical engine onto the PCB. NPO changes the electrical interconnection structure by bringing the ASIC package and optical engine onto a shared high-performance substrate or interposer. This is more significant than simply moving the optical engine a few centimeters closer.

    5. Power Consumption and Thermal Management

    Reducing electrical channel length can improve energy efficiency because high-speed electrical signals require less compensation when the channel is shorter and better controlled. This is particularly important in high-capacity switches, where many optical interfaces operate simultaneously.

    OBO can reduce the electrical distance compared with conventional front-panel optics. NPO can further reduce the channel length by using a more integrated substrate arrangement.

    However, total system power depends on more than the electrical connection. Optical drivers, receivers, laser sources, switching ASICs, retimers where used, and cooling systems all contribute to the overall power budget.

    Thermal management also becomes more demanding as optical engines move closer to the ASIC. The ASIC may generate substantial heat, and nearby photonic components can have their own temperature sensitivity and operating limits.

    Key design considerations include:

    • Heat transfer between the switching ASIC and optical engines.

    • Thermal isolation or temperature control for sensitive optical components.

    • Airflow or liquid-cooling arrangements around densely integrated assemblies.

    • Thermal expansion across the PCB, substrate, and package materials.

    • Long-term reliability under repeated operating-temperature changes.

    NPO may reduce electrical interconnect power, but the resulting system must still meet the cooling and reliability requirements of the complete switch platform.

    6. Manufacturing, Reliability, and Maintenance

    OBO and NPO also create different manufacturing and service requirements. OBO uses board-mounted optical engines, which means the optical components must be assembled and tested as part of the system PCB process.

    NPO introduces a more specialized substrate and packaging arrangement. The ASIC package and optical engines must be electrically and mechanically compatible with the shared substrate. Depending on the implementation, separate testing before final assembly can help identify component-level defects.

    Operational FactorOBONPO
    AssemblyOptical engines mounted on the system PCBOptical engines integrated through a high-performance substrate
    TestingBoard-level and optical-engine validationSeparate component testing may be possible before final substrate assembly
    Mechanical complexityPCB mounting and fiber attachmentSubstrate, package, optical-engine, and fiber-interface coordination
    RepairDepends on board-level mounting and rework capabilityDepends on socketing and optical-engine replacement design
    Failure isolationRequires diagnosis of board-mounted components and electrical pathsRequires diagnosis across the ASIC, substrate, and optical-engine assembly
    Upgrade flexibilityLimited by board design and component compatibilityDepends on the platform's modularity and substrate architecture

    It is important not to assume that every NPO optical engine is field-replaceable or that every OBO design requires complete board replacement. Both depend on the actual mechanical interface, assembly process, and maintenance strategy.

    7. OBO vs NPO vs Pluggable Optics vs CPO

    OBO and NPO are part of a broader progression toward closer integration of optical and electronic components. Comparing all four architectures makes their relative positions clearer.

    ArchitectureOptical Engine PositionElectrical ConnectionIntegration Level
    Pluggable OpticsFront-panel transceiver cageASIC package through PCB to front-panel moduleLowest integration
    OBOOn the system PCB near the ASICASIC package through PCB traces to optical engineBoard-level integration
    NPONear the ASIC on a shared high-performance substrate or interposerShort substrate-level electrical connectionNear-package integration
    CPOIntegrated within the ASIC's common package architectureShort package-level electrical connectionCo-packaged integration

    Pluggable optics prioritize module replacement and flexibility. OBO moves optical conversion onto the board. NPO brings the optical engine closer through a shared substrate. CPO integrates the optical engine and switching ASIC within a common package architecture.

    These approaches should not be treated as mandatory stages in a single migration path. Different switch platforms may adopt different architectures according to bandwidth requirements, manufacturing capabilities, thermal constraints, and operational priorities.

    8. Applications in 800G and 1.6T Data Center Networks

    The demand for higher switching capacity in AI data centers is increasing pressure on the electrical interfaces between switch ASICs and optical engines. As 800G and 1.6T networking platforms develop, the available PCB routing space, electrical channel loss, module power, and front-panel density become important system-level constraints.

    OBO and NPO offer different ways to address these challenges.

    • 800G switching platforms: OBO and NPO architectures can be evaluated where conventional front-panel electrical channels become difficult to support at the required density and power envelope.

    • 1.6T switching platforms: Higher electrical lane rates increase the importance of substrate design, short electrical paths, and optical-engine integration.

    • AI scale-out networks: High-bandwidth optical connectivity between GPU racks and network switches makes port density and system power important design factors.

    • Hyperscale data centers: Large switch deployments can benefit from improvements in aggregate interconnect power and physical integration.

    It is important to distinguish optical data rate from packaging architecture. An 800G or 1.6T interface defines the nominal transmission capacity, while OBO and NPO define how the optical engine is physically integrated with the switching system.

    Actual system performance depends on the switch ASIC, electrical interface, optical engine, network topology, fiber infrastructure, and workload traffic pattern.

    9. How to Select Between OBO and NPO

    The decision should be based on the complete switch platform rather than the optical engine's physical position alone.

    OBO may be appropriate when:

    • The platform requires board-level optical integration without a shared high-performance ASIC substrate.

    • The PCB electrical channel can support the required lane rate and signal-integrity limits.

    • The manufacturer has an established board-level assembly and testing process.

    • The optical-engine placement and fiber routing fit the system's mechanical design.

    • The overall power and cooling requirements can be met with the selected architecture.

    NPO may be appropriate when:

    • Reducing the ASIC-to-optical-engine electrical path is a major design objective.

    • The platform supports a suitable high-performance substrate or interposer.

    • Higher optical density is required around the switching ASIC.

    • The manufacturer can support the associated packaging and thermal requirements.

    • The optical-engine replacement and maintenance strategy is clearly defined.

    Before selecting either architecture, engineers should evaluate electrical channel loss, SerDes compatibility, optical performance, fiber attachment, thermal limits, component reliability, manufacturing yield, and long-term maintenance costs.

    10. Conclusion

    NPO and On-Board Optics are two approaches to moving optical engines closer to high-performance switch ASICs. OBO mounts the optical engine on the main system PCB, reducing the distance compared with front-panel pluggable optics while retaining PCB-based high-speed electrical routing.

    NPO uses a more integrated substrate or interposer arrangement to connect the ASIC package and optical engine. This can further shorten the electrical path and improve signal integrity and interconnect power efficiency, but it introduces additional packaging, thermal, and manufacturing considerations.

    For 800G and 1.6T data center switches, both architectures are relevant to the evolution of high-density optical connectivity. The best choice depends on electrical channel requirements, optical-engine design, system power, thermal performance, manufacturing capability, and maintenance strategy.

    For conventional high-speed optical connectivity, including 400G, 800G, and 1.6T transceiver solutions, visit the C-LIGHT optical transceiver portfolio. For product compatibility and network connectivity requirements, Contact C-LIGHT.

    For any questions, please contact us by email or WhatsApp.

    Email: sales@c-light.com

    WhatsApp: +86 132 6656 7067

    Related Articles

    Call
    Top